How much work is involved in an A/P Audit?
Judy wright
January 2023
A/P Recovery Audit is a crucial and time-consuming task. It involves many different processes, and the amount of work varies depending upon different factors. These factors include the size and complexity of the organization, the scope of the audit, the quality of existing controls and documentation, and the level of expertise of the audit team. Here is a summary of the key factors that determine the workload of the A/P audit.
- Scope of the Audit:
The scope of an Accounts Payable recovery audit typically involves the following: - Invoice Processing: Here, the auditor checks the accuracy and correctness of invoice and payment processes.
- Vendor Payments: The auditor reviews the vendor payments to ensure that duplicate payments or over payments are not made mistakenly or deliberately.
- Contract Compliance: The A/P recovery audit also ensures that the payments made to the vendors are in compliance with the agreement between both parties.
- Internal Controls: If the internal controls are weak, there is high risk of fraud and errors. This is a very sensitive area, and the audit must assess the controls thoroughly.
- Data Analysis: Audit teams must have expertise in data analysis, as this is a key tool used to find trends and anomalies.
- Vendor Master File: A/P audit also examines the vendor master file for accuracy. This master file contains key details about the vendor relationships.
- Recovery Opportunities: The major objective of the A/P audit is to identify and recover lost funds.
- Reporting and Recommendations: The final task of the audit team is to report the findings and to suggest preventative measures that the company can use to improve efficiency and financial stability.
The scope of the audit also defines the extent of examination, the time period required to assess everything included in the scope, and the volume of transactions to be assessed. The time period required to complete the audit also depends upon the audit team’s efficiency and professionalism.
- Data Collection:
An early step of the A/P audit is for the audit team to gather data and relevant documents. Data collection involves obtaining access to a company’s A/P systems, invoices, payment records, vendor contracts, and other supporting documentation. The auditor has a responsibility to examine all the relevant documents and data, which is a time-consuming task. However, as this data analysis helps the audit team to identify trends, anomalies, and areas of risk, the audit team cannot overlook this thorough examination. - Detailed Internal Controls Review:
Internal control review is a lengthy process. It requires the auditor to thoroughly check all the internal controls set in the organization to avoid fraud and errors. If the controls are weak, there are chances that the financial statements do not give the true and fair view of the company’s business. Detailed internal controls review as part of an Accounts Payable (A/P) recovery audit involves: - Invoice Approval Procedures: Auditors thoroughly check how the invoices are approved. They also verify supporting documents and review the segregation of duties to ensure that any payment does not go unauthorized.
- Invoice Coding Accuracy: Auditors also ensure that correct posting is made in the correct account and all the expenses are appropriately allocated to the respective accounts or cost centers to avoid incorrect classification.
- Payment Authorization Protocols: The audit team should also ensure that all the protocols are followed properly while authorizing payments. For instance, dual authorization requirements for large payments, approval thresholds, etc.
- Review of Exception Handling Procedures: The audit team should also review the procedures for treating exceptions and discrepancies, such as invoice discrepancies, payment disputes, or vendor inquiries.
- Audit Trail and Documentation: The auditor must ensure that adequate audit trail and documentation is available within the A/P process. Records of invoice approvals, payment authorizations, reconciliation reports, and audit trail for system changes or modifications should exist.
- Compliance with Policies and Regulations: Another duty of the audit team is to ensure that all the A/P processes are being carried out in accordance with existing policies and procedures.
- Testing Procedures:
Auditors use multiple testing procedures to check the accuracy, completeness, and validity of accounts payable (A/P) transactions during an audit. These procedures help auditors verify that A/P balances and transactions are properly recorded and reported. Here are some common A/P testing procedures for auditors:
- Sampling: Auditors check a sample of A/P transactions to ensure accuracy.
- Vouching: Auditors trace payments back to supporting documents such as invoices.
- Cutoff Testing: Auditors ensure expenses are recorded in the correct accounting period.
- Duplicate Payment Testing: Auditors also check for duplicate invoices or payments.
- Accrual Testing: Verify outstanding invoices to record expenses correctly.
- Vendor Confirmation: Confirm A/P balances and transactions with vendors.
- Analytical Procedures: Assess A/P balances based on historical trends.
- Reconciliation Testing: Review bank and vendor reconciliations for accuracy.
- Compliance Testing: Check if A/P processes comply with internal policies.
- Fraud Detection Procedures: Look for signs of fraud or irregularities in A/P transactions.
- Communication and Collaboration:
It is very important for the audit team to maintain timely communication and collaborate on the project with the stakeholders. They should interact with the staff and other stakeholders (such as vendors, management, etc.) to ask for necessary information, and also disclose any necessary information they consider crucial for the betterment of the business. Moreover, they are also responsible for timely reporting and disclosure to management. - Reporting and Documentation:
Auditors need to report audit findings, conclusions, and recommendations of the audit process. Their duty includes preparing audit reports, summarizing findings, documenting control deficiencies, and providing suggestions for improvement of the processes.
The amount of work for an AP audit can vary greatly from one situation to another. It all depends on what’s going on in the company and what needs to be reviewed. But no matter how much work it is, good planning, execution, and communication are very important. That’s how we make sure we’re on top of everything to give you the best audit results possible.